SAVINASAVINA

Machine-translated from Vietnamese. The Vietnamese version is authoritative. Read the Vietnamese original →

1:16 Ratio in Pour-Over Brewing: The Boundary Defining a Balanced Cup of Coffee

Learn how a 1:16 coffee-to-water ratio helps control Extraction Yield (EY) and Total Dissolved Solids (TDS) to avoid under-extraction or over-extraction errors.

1:16 Brewing Ratio: A Standard Formula or a Starting Point?

In manual pour-over brewing, the 1:16 ratio is commonly used as a starting point because it is relatively easy to apply and can produce a cup with a strength suitable for many palates. For example, 15 g of coffee combined with 240 g of water corresponds to a coffee-to-water ratio of 1:16 by weight.

However, it is important to distinguish between a popular formula and a mandatory standard. The 1:16 ratio is not the only ratio defined by the Specialty Coffee Association (SCA) as optimal for all coffee types and filtration methods. The appropriate ratio also depends on bean characteristics, roast level, grind size, water temperature, equipment, pouring technique, and drinker preference.

To understand why 1:16 is often chosen, we need to consider the relationship between the brewing ratio, dissolved solids concentration, and extraction yield.

1. Why is the 1:16 ratio commonly used?

The brewing ratio describes the relationship between the mass of dry coffee and the amount of water used. With the notation 1:16, every 1 g of coffee corresponds to 16 g of brewing water.

  • 15 g coffee: use 240 g water.
  • 20 g coffee: use 320 g water.
  • 25 g coffee: use 400 g water.

This ratio is a convenient practical benchmark for many pour-over recipes. It allows the brewer to start with a relatively clear amount of water, then adjust based on the actual results in the cup. If the coffee is too strong, try increasing the water ratio; if it is too weak, try decreasing the water ratio or increasing the amount of coffee.

Nevertheless, it cannot be claimed that 1:16 always produces the best balance. A light-roasted coffee, a dark-roasted Robusta, and an Arabica with a different flavor structure may require their own specific formulas. The goal is to find the right combination of strength, extraction level, and desired sensory attributes.

You can explore the topic of coffee brewing and extraction to learn about the factors affecting the brewing process.

2. What does the SCA Brewing Control Chart tell us?

The Coffee Brewing Control Chart illustrates the relationship between two key quantities: the concentration of total dissolved solids in the beverage (TDS) and the Extraction Yield (EY). The diagonal lines on the chart represent different coffee-to-water ratios.

In the commonly used version of the SCA chart, the traditional target zone is typically described as an extraction yield of approximately 18–22% and a TDS of approximately 1.15–1.45%. Some documents or equipment testing standards use a narrower TDS range. Therefore, when citing these figures, it is necessary to specify the chart or standard being applied.

Extraction Yield (EY)

EY represents the percentage of the initial dry coffee mass that is dissolved and transferred into the beverage. For example, an EY of 20% means that the amount of dissolved solids obtained is equivalent to approximately 20% of the initial dry coffee mass, according to the extraction calculation method used.

Total Dissolved Solids (TDS)

TDS represents the proportion of dissolved solids in the beverage, usually expressed as a percentage and measured using a refractometer specialized for coffee. TDS relates to the strength of the beverage but does not directly indicate the total amount of material extracted from the coffee grounds.

Two cups of coffee with similar TDS can still have different EYs. Conversely, two cups with similar EYs can differ in TDS. This difference stems from the amount of coffee used, the volume of beverage obtained, and the proportion of dissolved solids in the final product.

Learn more at: TDS – Total Dissolved Solids and coffee extraction yield.

3. Why does the 1:16 ratio not guarantee an EY within the 18–22% range?

The brewing ratio indicates the amount of water used relative to the coffee mass, but it does not fully describe how the water contacts and dissolves compounds in the coffee grounds. The extraction result is also influenced by various other variables.

  • Grind size and particle size distribution: affect surface area, dissolution rate, and flow resistance.
  • Water temperature: impacts dissolution rate and the characteristics of extraction processes.
  • Contact time: affects the extent to which compounds transfer from coffee grounds to water.
  • Pouring and agitation technique: affects wetting efficiency, flow dynamics, and extraction uniformity.
  • Brewer and filter paper: cone shape, drainage holes, and filter paper properties can alter drainage rate and beverage body.
  • Coffee bean characteristics: variety, processing method, roast level, and freshness all influence extractability and flavor.

Therefore, a 1:16 ratio should be viewed as a starting point for recipe development, not an automatic mechanism that places every cup within the target zone. The brewer must assess concentration, extraction yield, and sensory qualities before deciding to adjust parameters.

4. What happens when the brewing ratio is changed?

When other conditions remain relatively stable, increasing the amount of water relative to coffee typically results in a more diluted beverage; reducing the amount of water usually makes the beverage more concentrated. However, changing the ratio can also affect EY, depending on the brewing method and how water passes through the coffee bed.

4.1. Lower water ratios, such as 1:12 or 1:14

Recipes using less water per gram of coffee generally produce beverages with higher concentration if other factors are similar. However, it cannot be concluded that a 1:12 or 1:14 ratio necessarily causes under-extraction.

Actual EY also depends on grind size, temperature, contact time, wetting efficiency, and flow uniformity. A concentrated recipe can still achieve high EY; conversely, a concentrated recipe with uneven extraction may still taste sharply sour or unbalanced.

4.2. Higher water ratios, such as 1:18 or 1:20

Increasing the amount of water generally lowers TDS if the coffee dose and other conditions remain constant. However, a low-concentration beverage does not equate to over-extraction.

A 1:18 recipe can produce a more diluted but still balanced cup. Conversely, a 1:16 recipe can still yield undesirable extraction results if grind size, flow, or brewing technique are inappropriate.

Therefore, brewing ratio alone should not be used to diagnose under- or over-extraction. It is necessary to combine TDS and EY data, if measurable, with sensory evaluation of the beverage.

5. Under-extraction and over-extraction: How to identify them?

Under-extraction

Under-extraction is commonly used to describe cases where the amount of dissolved solids obtained is lower than desired for a specific recipe. On the traditional Brewing Control Chart, an EY below approximately 18% falls outside the reference target zone. However, this threshold is not an absolute boundary for determining the quality of all coffee types.

Sensory-wise, an improperly extracted cup may exhibit sharp acidity, unclear sweetness, a thin mouthfeel, or a short aftertaste. These signs are not specific to under-extraction: light-roast coffee naturally has prominent acidity, and bean quality or brewing technique can also produce similar manifestations.

When under-extraction is suspected, try grinding one step finer, adjusting water temperature within an appropriate range, or improving pouring uniformity. Change only one variable at a time to identify the factor that truly improves flavor.

Over-extraction

Over-extraction is commonly used to describe cases where the amount of dissolved solids extracted exceeds the target zone of the recipe or causes the flavor to become unbalanced. On the traditional reference chart, an EY above approximately 22% falls outside the target zone; this does not mean that every cup with a higher EY tastes bad.

Sensory-wise, a coffee cup may exhibit strong bitterness, a dry aftertaste, or astringency. However, these sensations are not caused by a single group of compounds and cannot be simply explained by the rapid dissolution of tannins at the end of the process.

Bitterness or astringency may be related to bean characteristics, roast level, uneven extraction distribution, and other brewing conditions. If issues arise, try grinding one step coarser, reducing agitation, or adjusting pouring technique, then re-evaluate the results.

6. Optimizing the 1:16 ratio in practice

Instead of considering 1:16 as a mandatory formula, use it as a benchmark to conduct controlled experiments. The following procedure is suitable when starting to develop a formula for a manual filter.

  1. Grind and water: Start with 15 g of coffee and 240 g of water, or adjust both quantities in the same ratio.
  2. Keep conditions relatively stable: Use the same type of beans, roast level, equipment, and water source in each comparative test.
  3. Assess flavor: Record the intensity, acidity, bitterness, sweetness, aftertaste, and mouthfeel.
  4. Adjust individual variables: Try changing the grind size first, then adjust the ratio, temperature, or pouring technique if needed.
  5. Measure TDS and calculate EY when possible: Use a coffee refractometer and actual drink volume to check results, rather than guessing EY from the ratio only.

To calculate EY approximately by weight, you can use the following formula:

EY (%) = [Drink volume obtained × TDS (%)] / Dry coffee weight

In this formula, the drink volume obtained does not necessarily equal the amount of water poured, as some water is retained in the coffee grounds and filter. When using TDS as a percentage, apply consistent units of measurement in the calculation.

7. Always remember that 1:16 is a starting point, but not the absolute answer

The 1:16 ratio has practical value because it is easy to calculate and suitable for starting many brewing recipes. However, coffee quality cannot be determined solely by a single number.

TDS helps evaluate the drink's concentration; EY describes the ratio of dissolved solids obtained compared to the initial dry coffee weight; while sensory evaluation determines whether the result meets the desired flavor goals. These three perspectives complement each other, rather than replacing one another.

When understanding the relationship between brewing ratio, TDS, EY, and sensory evaluation, the brewer can adjust the formula with a solid basis, rather than trying to follow a single ratio for all types of coffee.


References

  1. Specialty Coffee Association (SCA). Brewing Best Practices. Document on coffee-to-water ratio, brewing temperature, grind size, contact time, and process control factors. Read the document.
  2. Guinard, J.-X. et al. (2023). A new Coffee Brewing Control Chart relating sensory properties and consumer liking to brew strength, extraction yield, and brew ratio. Journal of Food Science. Expanded research on considering the relationship between drink concentration, extraction yield, brewing ratio, and consumer perception. View the research article.
  3. Liang, J., Chan, K. C., and Ristenpart, W. D. (2021). An equilibrium desorption model for the strength and extraction yield of full immersion brewed coffee. Scientific Reports, 11, 6904. Research on the impact of brewing ratio on TDS and extraction yield in immersion brewing. View the full research article.
  4. Specialty Coffee Association of America (SCAA, 2015). Golden Cup Standard. Document on drink concentration, extraction yield, and coffee-to-water ratio standards. View the document.

Note: The documents above use different methods, application ranges, and standard versions. The TDS and EY ranges mentioned in the article are traditional reference ranges, not absolute quality limits for all coffee types or brewing methods. The 1:16 ratio is presented as a practical starting point, not the only ratio specified by SCA.

Vietnam Clean Coffee · Knowledge Library · caphesachvietnam.com
Back to the library →